Pork pies are a quintessential British snack – a handheld meat pie encased in pastry. What makes them distinctly pork pies is their traditional jelly filling. However in recent years there has been much debate about the disappearance of jelly from modern pork pies. Where has the jelly gone, and why has it vanished from many pork pies today? This article will take a deep dive into the history, controversy and possible future of jelly in the iconic pork pie.
A Brief History of Jelly in Pork Pies
Jelly has long been an integral part of the traditional pork pie recipe Pork pies originated in the early 19th century in Melton Mowbray, a rural town in Leicestershire, England At this time, pork pies were handcrafted with a hot water crust pastry and filled with uncured pork and the jelly made from the boiled pigs’ trotters.
This aspic jelly served several purposes
- It kept the pie contents moist and prevented the pastry from becoming soggy
- It held the pie filling together so it wouldn’t crumble apart
- It added an extra layer of flavor
As the pies were often carried long distances by hunters on horseback, the jelly helped maintain the structural integrity of the pie. Melton Mowbray pork pies even earned a reputation for staying perfectly intact after a bumpy ride!
For generations, jelly remained a standard component of pork pies across England. The Melton Mowbray Pork Pie Association, founded in 1998, fought to gain Protected Geographical Indication status for their pies to protect the traditional recipe, including the signature pork jelly.
When Did Jelly Disappear from Pork Pies?
The quantity of jelly in pork pies remained consistent until around the 1960s and 70s. During this era, pork pie production became increasingly industrialized, with machines taking over the handcrafting process. Commercial manufacturers found that producing aspic jelly on a large scale took considerable time and effort.
To cut costs and streamline production, many brands chose to reduce the amount of jelly or remove it completely from their pies. Consumers grew accustomed to these new jelly-free pies, and they became the norm.
However, some traditional, high-end pork pie makers continued using jelly in their recipes. Additionally, homemade recipes allow hobby bakers to add as much jelly as they desire. The disappearance of jelly is primarily an issue with mass-produced, commercial pork pies.
Why Has Jelly Disappeared from Most Modern Pork Pies?
There are a few factors that contributed to the decline of jelly in the majority of store-bought pork pies:
Changing Consumer Tastes
As jelly-free pork pies flooded the market, consumer preferences evolved. The public became less concerned about jelly’s functional benefits and more attracted to its aesthetic appeal (or lack thereof).
The wobbly, moist texture and appearance of jelly may have begun to seem unappetizing to some modern palates. Manufacturers responded to this shift in taste by limiting or removing jelly from their pies.
Cost-Cutting Measures
Adding jelly to pork pies requires extra ingredients, time, labor and specialized equipment to produce. By eliminating jelly from their recipes, producers can cut down on costs and maximize profits. This financial incentive likely factored into many brands’ decisions.
Lack of Quality Ingredients
Aspic jelly uses gelatin from animal bones, typically pigs’ trotters, to solidify and add flavor. In today’s industrial food system, acquiring high-quality bones for stock can be challenging and expensive. Lower grade ingredients result in poor jelly texture and taste. To avoid this issue, most commercial producers skip the jelly altogether.
The Controversy Around Jelly in Pork Pies
The disappearance of jelly from pork pies has sparked debate and controversy among culinary experts and pie enthusiasts.
On one side of the issue, traditionalists argue that jelly is an indispensable component of an authentic pork pie. The unique texture and savory flavor it provides cannot be replicated. Removing the jelly detracts from the classic experience and quality of eating a pork pie.
On the other side, more modern perspectives suggest that jelly is not actually essential to enjoy a pork pie. Some consider it unappetizing or superfluous. They appreciate contemporary pork pies for their convenience as an easy, handheld snack.
This has created disagreement around what defines a “real” pork pie in today’s food culture. The opposing viewpoints seem unlikely to reach a consensus any time soon.
Will Jelly Make a Comeback in Pork Pies?
The future of jelly in pork pies remains uncertain. However, there are a few factors that may contribute to a partial jelly revival:
-
A growing interest in traditional, artisanal food preparation could increase demand for heritage recipes like the Melton Mowbray pork pie with jelly.
-
New technologies may enable more efficient, large-scale jelly production using quality ingredients. This could make it economical for brands to re-introduce some jelly.
-
Food trends tend to move in cycles – the pendulum may swing back towards appreciating jelly’s retro appeal.
-
Innovative uses of flavored, colored, or molded jelly in pies could modernize it and increase appeal.
-
Boutique pie shops committed to authenticity may help jelly’s reputation and popularity recover.
While jelly may not dominate modern pork pies as it once did, a niche market for traditionally jellied pies will likely endure. Promoting jelly’s benefits could even convert a new generation of pork pie lovers. For now, jelly fans can still enjoy this historic ingredient by seeking out specialty pie makers or trying their hand at homemade recipes. The humble pork pie has more chapters yet to come in its evolving story!
Frequently Asked Questions About Jelly in Pork Pies
What is pork pie jelly traditionally made from?
The jelly in traditional pork pies is called aspic. It is made by slowly simmering pig trotters or other pork bones to create a rich, savory stock. Gelatin is extracted from the bones, and the stock naturally solidifies into a wiggly gel when chilled.
Does jelly help preserve the pork pie filling?
Yes, the jelly acts as a seal around the pie filling and protects it from drying out. The moist environment and antimicrobial properties of jelly prevent spoilage. Before refrigeration, jelly was essential for giving pork pies a longer shelf life.
What flavor does pork pie jelly impart?
The jelly has a concentrated, meaty pork flavor from the boiled bones. It also provides a hint of saltiness. The jelly overall accentuates and balances the flavors of the pork filling.
Is it difficult to make pork pie jelly at home?
It can be time-consuming to extract and clarify homemade bone broth for jelly. However, there are shortcuts available using powdered gelatin, stock cubes or canned broth to set the aspic more easily. Adding herbs and spices can boost the flavor.
Are there vegetarian alternatives to pork jelly?
For vegetarian pork pies, the jelly can be made using vegan gelatin like agar agar or pectin. Vegetable stocks can provide flavor instead of meat broth. Tofu can even be blended into the jelly for added protein.
Conclusion
While its glory days may have passed, jelly still retains an important place in pork pie tradition. The moist, wobbly texture and rich savoriness of jelly is an experience to be savored. As food culture evolves, perhaps new generations will rediscover pork pies’ jellied origins. In the meantime, we can pay homage to this history by seeking out quality pies made the classic way. The unique pleasure of biting into a pork pie and tasting its smooth jelly filling is one worth preserving.