The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Turkey Call

If I try to purr on a diaphragm I can make a sound, but it won’t be a turkey call. On the other hand, with my slate call I can purr, yelp, cutt, cluck, tree cackle, and even kee-kee run without much practice. The ease of creating realistic calls is why I rely heavily on a slate call each spring.

But the “slate call” I use most often is actually a glass call, which brings up the confusing topic of turkey call nomenclature. Technically what I have reviewed here is a roster of the best pot calls. There are five common surfaces for pot calls: slate, glass, crystal, ceramic and aluminum. However all of these are commonly referred to as “slate calls” despite not all of them having any slate in their construction. So to keep things simple, and to make sure you get a review of all the best calls on the market, I’m including all pot call surface types in this review and I’m labeling them all “slate calls.”

I tested 14 of the best slate calls on the market to bring you my top ten picks. The calls I’ve tested range from under $20 budget options to premium production calls around $100. Here are my top choices.

Turkey hunting takes skill, patience, and the right gear Having the best turkey call can make the difference between a successful hunt and an empty tag. With so many types of turkey calls on the market, it can be overwhelming to pick the right one for you. This comprehensive guide will walk you through the pros and cons of the top turkey calls to help you choose the best option for your hunting style and skill level.

Overview of Turkey Call Types

There are 5 main types of turkey calls to consider:

  • Slate Calls: Also known as pot calls. Made of slate, glass, crystal, ceramic, or aluminum. Produce realistic hen sounds by scraping a striker across the surface. Great for beginners and close range calling.

  • Box Calls Wooden boxes with a plexiglass top Use a wooden paddle to mimic hen yelps Excellent for open fields and long distance calling.

  • Mouth Calls: Small, versatile call that fits in your mouth. Takes practice to use but allows hands-free operation. The go-to for experienced hunters.

  • Push Button Calls: Uses a plunger mechanism to create hen yelps with the push of a button. Easy to use even for novices. Lacks versatility of other options.

  • Wing Bone Calls: Simple, V-shaped calls made from turkey wing bones. Takes an expert hand to sound realistic. Mostly a novelty item.

When choosing a call, consider your skill level, hunting environment, and personal preferences. Many hunters use multiple call types to produce the most realistic and versatile sounds.

Best Turkey Calls Reviewed

Based on expert tests and reviews from leading hunting sources, here are the top-rated turkey calls in 5 categories:

Best Overall: Houndstooth Game Calls Dixie Hen Slate

This versatile, American-made slate call consistently earns top marks for ease of use and sound quality. The innovative horizontal laminate construction amplifies volume and resonance. It excels at delivering raspy, excited hen yelps that convince toms to close the distance. Perfect for beginners and seasoned hunters alike.

Best Box Call: Lynch World Champion Box Call

This classic box call produces loud, realistic yelps that carry over long distances. The patented angled sides project sound while preventing distortion. Features a beautiful mahogany body and scratch-resistant plexiglass. Adjustable sliding lid allows fine tuning of tone and volume. A premium choice for open fields.

Best Mouth Call: Woodhaven Custom Calls Ninja Ghost Mouth Call

With expertly tuned reeds, this versatile diaphragm call creates sharp cuts, excited yelps, clucks, and purrs. Its proprietary reed system allows for an array of realistic sounds. The flexible rubber frame fits comfortably for all-day calling. It takes practice, but rewards dedicated hunters with superior calling abilities.

Best Slate: Zink Wicked Series Slate

This reasonably priced slate produces raspy, high-pitched yelps perfect for aggressive calling. The innovative wood laminate and tight grain slate offer excellent volume and resonance. Includes a easy-grip striker with rubber inserts to prevent slipping. A great choice for close range calling under $50.

Best Push Button Call: Quaker Boy ‘Cyclone’ Easy Yelper

This push button call is incredibly user-friendly for beginners of all ages. Just press the button to emit loud, realistic yelps at the perfect cadence. The cyclone shaped pot projects sound while the slate surface produces an authentic raspy tone. It lacks versatility but excels at delivering consistent yelps.

What to Look for in a Turkey Call

With an overview of the top options, here are key factors to evaluate when choosing your call:

  • Sound Quality: The most lifelike, realistic sounds convince wary birds. Listen to recordings of top-rated calls to determine sound profile.

  • Build Quality: Durable materials and fine craftsmanship ensure years of service. Poor construction affects sound. Feel for sturdy pots, tight seams, and smooth strikers.

  • Ease of Use: Look for calls noted as beginner-friendly. Consider push button or box calls if new to hunting. Mouth calls require expert breath control.

  • Weather Resistance: Wood calls falter in wet conditions. All-weather materials like aluminum, crystal, and synthetics excel in rain and moisture.

  • Range: Box and slate calls project different volumes. Box calls carry farther while slates excel up close. Factor in your hunting environment.

  • Price: Sets expectations for sound quality and materials. Premium calls over $100 offer exceptional sound but budget options under $50 can still be effective.

Tips for Using Turkey Calls

Once you’ve selected the right call, effective use takes practice:

  • Use proper grip and pressure – A loose hold prevents muffling the call. Match pressure to volume desired.

  • Master cadence and rhythm – Hens use patterns of clucks, purrs, and yelps. Mimic natural pacing.

  • Vary sounds – Cycle through different calls to sound like a flock of hens.

  • Listen to real hens – Learn nuances like squeaks, whistles and excited tremors to make your calling ultra-realistic.

  • Start soft – Loud calls can spook birds. Work up to aggressive calling as they get closer.

With the right turkey call and proper technique, you’ll be ready to fill your tag this spring. Use this guide to zero in on the perfect option to match your budget and hunting style.

what is the best turkey call

Best Glass: Woodhaven Cherry Classic Crystal

Key Features

  • Includes two strikers, conditioning kit, and lid
  • Can be customized with engraving or photos under the crystal
  • Made from quarter-sawn cherry
  • Also available in slate
  • Made in USA
  • Price: $95

Pros

  • High pitched and raspy
  • Loud
  • Well made

Cons

  • Can’t call as softly as others

what is the best turkey call

If you want to make raspy, two-tone yelps and aggressive cutts that reach the next ridge, the Cherry Classic needs to be in your vest. It produces complex notes compared to the one-dimensional sounds you get from lesser calls. It excels at yelps and cutts, but takes a little finesse for purrs. A tip for purring on this call is to move your hand up the striker, use very light pressure, and use a freshly conditioned area. Its overall high pitch allows it to kee-kee really well. Just move your striker toward the edge for kee-kees.

The quarter-sawn cherry is gorgeous, and the call as a whole is done beautifully. It’s a call worth every cent of its $95 price tag.

Another great crystal call is the Woodhaven Ninja Crystal, which has been my go-to for years.

Best Pot Calls: Reviews and Recommendations

Key Features

  • Walnut and cherry horizontal laminate pot
  • Slate over glass
  • Comes with a Dymondwood striker
  • Lifetime warranty (Full refunds available within 90 days of purchase)
  • Price: $97

Pros

  • Great sound quality
  • Excels at mid to close-range calling

Cons

  • My sample had some fit and finish flaws

what is the best turkey call

The Old Hunter Classic brings out the best sound qualities of slate through some innovative construction. Esh combines two of the best pot call woods, cherry and walnut, in a horizontal laminate. The cherry is at the bottom and walnut on top, unlike most calls that use a vertical lamination. They also use a glass soundboard and a Dymondwood striker. Those elements combined with quality slate produce a great-sounding turkey call.

The Old Hunter Classic isn’t as loud or high pitched as the Cherry Classic, but it’s not meant to be. Slate calls shine at convincing a tom to close the distance. Raspy, excited-hen yelps and cluck and purrs, are this call’s bread and butter.

My call has some minor but noticeable fit and finish issues, mainly rough spots and glue specs on the pot, which you don’t expect on a nearly $100 call. Yet, I love the sound quality, and the call is very nice overall.

This is THE BEST Turkey Call for Beginners… | Buck Junkie Outdoors

FAQ

What is the most realistic sounding turkey call?

If you are new to turkey calling, you may want to start with something simple like a push-button or box call. For more seasoned hunters, a slate or diaphragm call delivers more realistic sounds and versatility to help you fill your tag.

What is the best sound to call in a turkey?

The sharp, crisp sounds of a cluck are mainly used in close range calling situations. When an approaching tom hangs up in sight of your setup, a cluck will often pull him the rest of the way in. Clucks are good to use at the end of a series of yelps and, when made softly, pair well with purrs.

Leave a Comment