Is Cajun Turkey Spicy? Everything You Need to Know About This Zesty Holiday Bird

This Cajun Spiced Roasted Turkey uses a dry rub brine for crispy skin with a spicy kick! It’s also injected with butter and herbs to keep the bird tender, moist, and loaded with flavor.

Thanksgiving turkey gets a bad rep. To be honest, rightfully so! Sometimes I’ve shown up for the holiday meal and the turkey was bland and way too dry! Luckily there are methods to combat both of these.

This one is served using a dry Cajun rub. If you aren’t a fan of spicy, try using a Creole seasoning or whatever you love to use to season poultry.

Cajun turkey is a popular alternative to traditional roasted turkey for the holidays Its name comes from the unique Cajun seasoning blend used to flavor the meat But is Cajun turkey actually spicy? The answer depends on a few factors,

What Makes Cajun Turkey Different

Cajun turkey gets its signature flavor from being rubbed with a blend of spices before cooking. This Cajun seasoning typically contains peppers like cayenne and black pepper along with other spices like garlic, onion, thyme, oregano, and more.

The seasoning blend is often mixed into a Cajun herb butter that is slathered under the skin and over the meat. The butter helps the seasoning stick to the turkey and keeps it moist during roasting.

Some Cajun turkey recipes also call for injecting a spicy Cajun marinade deep into the meat This amps up the flavor even more

So while traditional roasted turkey is seasoned with just salt, pepper, sage, and thyme, Cajun turkey packs much more punch.

How Spicy Is Cajun Seasoning?

The level of heat in Cajun seasoning can vary quite a bit between brands. Some blends are designed to be mild so they have broad appeal. These will add lots of flavor without too much bite.

Other Cajun seasonings are intentionally spicier. They contain more cayenne pepper and other hot chile powders. Using a hotter blend will result in a turkey with some serious kick.

As a general rule, if you see words like “spicy,” “hot,” or “extra spicy” on the label, you can expect a good dose of heat. Seasonings labeled as “mild” are less likely to make your guests break a sweat.

Ingredients That Add Heat

Here are some of the ingredients commonly found in Cajun seasoning that bring spice to the blend:

  • Cayenne pepper
  • Crushed red pepper
  • Chili powder
  • Paprika
  • Black pepper
  • Mustard powder
  • Hot sauce

The more of these incendiary ingredients in the mix, the spicier the overall flavor.

Tips for Controlling the Heat

If you want to infuse your turkey with lots of Cajun flavor but aren’t sure about the spice level, there are a few ways to control the heat:

  • Use a milder Cajun blend. Look for seasonings labeled “mild” or with lower Scoville units.

  • Use less seasoning. Start with a light coating over the turkey and add more later if needed. You can always amp it up but you can’t take it away.

  • Make your own. Create a custom spice mix with cayenne, paprika, garlic, thyme, and black pepper to your preferred spice level.

  • Add fat. Mixing the spices into an herb butter or oil will mellow the heat a bit.

  • Skip the marinade. Injecting a spicy Cajun liquid into the meat intensifies the heat. Rubbing on the outside adds milder flavor.

  • Serve with cooling sides. Offer yogurt raita, sour cream, or something creamy and cooling to balance the spices.

How to Tell if Your Cajun Turkey Will Be Spicy

Since so much depends on the particular seasoning blend used, it’s hard to give a definitive yes or no to the question “is Cajun turkey spicy?”

Here are some ways to get a sense of how hot your Cajun turkey will turn out before you cook it:

  • Read the seasoning label. Look for mentions of heat or scoville units.

  • Taste the seasoning. Lick a bit of the spice mix off your finger. If it burns, so will your turkey.

  • Do a test run. Rub a piece of chicken or tofu with the Cajun blend and cook it. Check for spiciness.

  • Add gradually. Start with a light coating and keep tasting and adding more as needed.

Balancing Heat with Flavor

While the signature heat is part of Cajun turkey’s appeal, you also want the blend to add lots of flavor. The best spice mixes will combine heat with aromatic herbs, warm spices, and savory depth.

Some flavor-boosting ingredients commonly found in Cajun blends include:

  • Onion
  • Garlic
  • Oregano
  • Thyme
  • Basil
  • Bay leaves
  • Mustard
  • Paprika
  • Celery seed
  • Lemongrass

This medley of flavors gives Cajun turkey complexity beyond just spicy heat. The result is a zesty, heady flavor that makes for a break from the usual holiday bird.

Putting It All Together

Cajun turkey can offer anything from a mild, savory kick to mouth-scorching heat, depending on the particular blend of spices used. Reading labels, tasting as you go, and using cooling sides can help manage the heat level.

Balancing the spicy peppers with herbs and aromatics creates depth and nuance. This makes Cajun turkey a great way to spice up your holiday table with festive Louisiana flair. Just be prepared with plenty of milk and bread!

is cajun turkey spicy

How to Thaw a Turkey

I recommend thawing in the refrigerator or in cold water.

If using the refrigerator, keep the turkey in it’s original packaging and place a sheet pan underneath to catch any juices that may leak out.

Here is the safety chart for thawing in the fridge according to the USDA: 4-12 pounds: 1 to 3 days 12-16 pounds: 3 to 4 days 16-20 pounds 4 to 5 days 20-24 pounds 5 to 6 days

Here is the safety chart for thawing in cold water according to the USDA:

4-12 pounds: 2 to 6 hours 12-16 pounds: 6 to 8 hours 16-20 pounds 8 to 10 hours 20-24 pounds 10 to 12 hours

Once thawed, it can stay in the fridge, safely, up to 2 days.

is cajun turkey spicy

How Big a Turkey Do You Need/How to Plan

The general rule of thumb is 1 pound of turkey per guest. If you have a small party you can even consider a turkey breast. This recipe breaks down the ingredient servings based on the size and weight of the turkey, 12 pounds in this case.

That will make it easy to scale down or scale up the servings you will need of each ingredient, by taking into account the weight of the turkey you are using.

is cajun turkey spicy

SPICY CAJUN SMOKED TURKEY (PREPPING)

FAQ

What does Cajun turkey taste like?

You can see all the seasoning on top, the beautiful white meat. Cheers, guys. Oh, you can taste that beautiful Popeye seasoning, the Cajun flavor. A little bit smoky, a little bit peppery, garlicky, oniony, and more.

Is Popeyes Cajun style turkey spicy?

Not spicy so kids should be okay.

Is Cajun considered spicy?

Myth #1: All Cajun Food Is Spicy We won’t argue with the last two adjectives, but you should know that not all Cajun food is spicy! Although it’s true that many traditional Cajun dishes pack a spicy punch, there are plenty of Cajun specialties that are simply well-seasoned.

Is Cajun seasoning supposed to be spicy?

Since—as mentioned above—Cajun seasoning is basically just a blend of cayenne pepper and garlic, Cajun flavor is most often described as equal parts bold and spicy (from the pepper) and earthy (from the garlic).

Leave a Comment