We followed your videos and cooked our 21-pound turkey stuffing-less at 450 degrees for 30 minutes and then turned the oven down to 350. It has now been 2 hours, 30 minutes, and the thigh is 150 with the instant thermometer. Could it really be that close to done? Should we turn down the heat? We had hoped to eat at 5:30. — Carla, N.Y. A.
Yes, if the turkey’s almost done, turn off the oven now to slow the cooking, and check the temperature as you’re getting closer to dinnertime. Once it’s done, take it out of the oven, and let it rest — a large bird needs to rest for about 45 minutes anyway. You can also loosely tent it with tin foil, if it’s not tented already. The turkey may cool off a bit, so serve with hot gravy.
The Dining staff is taking questions on cooking, drinking, entertaining or any other holiday hurdles. Tweet us at @nytimesdining using the hashtag #ThanksgivingQs, or post a question, and browse other readers’ questions, here. Thanksgiving recipes, videos and more are here.
Diner’s Journal is ceasing publication so that we can create a single Dining section destination: nytimes.com/dining. Read more…
Vary the marinade, and you can serve flank steak in endless variation all summer. Read more…
Diana Bush, a baker at the NoMad, works from 8 p.m. to dawn making the restaurant’s bread.Read more…
Cooking a turkey takes time and preparation. After brining, seasoning, and roasting your turkey to perfection, the last thing you want is for it to finish cooking way before your guests arrive. If your turkey is done too early, don’t panic! With some strategic planning, you can keep your turkey warm and delicious until it’s time to carve and serve.
How To Tell If Your Turkey Is Done
Before taking any action, you first need to confirm that your turkey is actually fully cooked Use a meat thermometer to check the internal temperature in multiple places
-
Insert the probe into the thickest part of the breast. Turkey breast should reach 165°F.
-
Check the thighs by inserting the thermometer into the thickest part Thighs should also hit 165°F
-
Check the innermost part of the wing, which should reach 165°F.
Once the breast, thighs, and wings are all above 165°F, your turkey is considered safely cooked through. If it reached temperature earlier than expected, you can hold it using one of the methods below.
Timeline For Holding Your Cooked Turkey
How long you need to hold your cooked turkey will determine the best approach. Here are common timeframes and techniques:
Less Than 1 Hour
If your turkey is done less than an hour before mealtime, the simplest method is letting it rest:
-
Cover the turkey pan tightly with aluminum foil to lock in heat.
-
Wrap the entire pan in towels for extra insulation.
Resting for up to an hour will keep your turkey hot and allow juices to reabsorb for maximum moisture.
1-2 Hours
For a longer hold of 1-2 hours, keep the turkey warm in a low oven:
-
Preheat oven to lowest temp (150°F – 170°F).
-
Add broth to turkey pan and tightly cover with foil.
-
Place foil-wrapped turkey in the oven. Monitor temperature to ensure oven doesn’t exceed 170°F.
The low oven will act as a warmer without continuing to cook the turkey.
2-4 Hours
For a hold time of 2-4 hours, use the “faux cambro” technique:
-
Get an insulated cooler and line with towels.
-
Bring water to a boil and fill cooler to heat interior. Empty water after 10 minutes.
-
Wrap turkey in foil and towels and place in cooler. Close lid.
The super-insulated cooler will keep your turkey piping hot for hours.
4+ Hours
If turkey is done 4+ hours early, it’s safest to refrigerate and reheat:
-
Allow turkey to rest 30 minutes, then carve meat from bones.
-
Refrigerate carved turkey in shallow containers to cool quickly.
-
Reheat slices in 200°F oven for 30 minutes before serving.
Should You Keep The Turkey Whole?
For shorter holds under 4 hours, keeping your turkey whole works well. Carved meat won’t hold heat as long.
However, for very long holds, carving your turkey once it rests allows the meat to cool faster in the fridge. Slices also reheat more quickly and evenly than a whole bird.
Steps To Take When Turkey Is Done Early
Follow this checklist if your turkey finishes cooking prematurely:
-
Verify doneness by checking internal temp in multiple spots.
-
Plan your approach based on how long until mealtime.
-
For under 1 hour hold, just let wrapped turkey rest.
-
For 1-2 hour hold, keep turkey warm at 150°F – 170°F oven.
-
For 2-4 hours, preheat a cooler and hold turkey wrapped inside.
-
If 4+ hours early, carve turkey and refrigerate until reheating.
-
Monitor temperature throughout to ensure food safety.
With the right technique for your timeline, you can relax knowing your turkey will be hot and delicious at serving time.
Troubleshooting A Fast-Cooking Turkey
If your test turkey always seems to cook too quickly, there are ways to slow things down:
-
Use a lower oven temp. Drop your target temp by 25°F-50°F.
-
Cook stuffing separately. Cooking the turkey stuffed will accelerate cooking.
-
Brush with oil or butter. Creating a barrier on the skin can prevent over-browning.
-
Cook to a lower final temp. Pull the turkey at 155°F and residual heat will carry it to 165°F.
-
Place a foil tent over the breast. This shields the lean breast meat from getting overdone.
-
Baste with broth. Keeping the turkey moist prevents it from cooking too fast.
With a few simple tweaks, you can slow down your turkey’s cook time and avoid an over-eager bird again!
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a cooked turkey stay warm?
A properly wrapped whole turkey can hold for 1-2 hours. Carved turkey should be eaten within 1 hour or refrigerated.
Can you keep a cooked turkey warm in the oven?
Yes, placing the foil-wrapped turkey in a 150°F – 170°F oven will keep it warm for 1-2 hours. Monitor temperature to prevent overcooking.
Is it OK to cook a turkey a day in advance?
It is safe to cook your turkey 1 day ahead. Let it rest, then refrigerate within 2 hours. Reheat thoroughly to 165°F before serving.
Can you freeze a fully cooked turkey?
Cooked turkey can be tightly wrapped, frozen, and thawed in the refrigerator within 2 days. Reheat to 165°F. Quality won’t be as good as fresh.
How do you reheat a cooked turkey?
Carved turkey can be reheated in a 200°F oven for 15-20 minutes until warmed through to 165°F. Add turkey drippings or broth for extra moisture.
Key Takeaways
-
Confirm your turkey is fully cooked by checking internal temperature in multiple spots.
-
Hold your turkey based on time needed: rest <1 hour, oven warm 1-2 hours, insulated cooler 2-4 hours, or refrigerate and reheat 4+ hours.
-
Monitor temps throughout holding to ensure food safety.
-
Carve turkey when holding over 4 hours to allow faster cooling and reheating.
-
Adjust roasting technique if your turkey always finishes too quickly.
With smart planning for the timeline and temperature control, you can perfectly hold a turkey that’s done ahead of schedule. Just stay calm, be prepared, and your Thanksgiving dinner will be amazing.
