Bone-In vs Boneless Which HoneyBaked Ham is Better?
When it comes to HoneyBaked hams, you have two main options – bone-in or boneless. But which style results in the most flavorful, juicy holiday ham? In this comprehensive guide, we’ll analyze the pros, cons, cost, preparation, taste and more to help you determine which HoneyBaked ham is best.
HoneyBaked Ham Overview
For the uninitiated, HoneyBaked Ham is a popular chain of stores that sells ready-to-eat hams and turkeys. Their hams are injected with a sweet glaze, slow-cooked, and spiral sliced for easy serving.
HoneyBaked offers both classic bone-in hams and boneless hams. Bone-in hams come directly off the bone for rich, deep flavor. Boneless hams offer convenience since the bone is removed before slicing.
Cost Comparison: Bone-In vs. Boneless HoneyBaked Ham
One of the biggest factors when choosing between bone-in and boneless is cost. Bone-in hams are generally more budget friendly since you’re paying for the weight of the bones too. A typical bone-in half ham costs $50-60 for 8-10 pounds.
Boneless hams clock in at $100 or more since the weight is 100% meat. A 6-8 pound boneless ham can run you $120-150. However, boneless hams allow more accurate portioning if you’re feeding a smaller crowd.
Consider how many servings you need and check for deals or coupons to offset the cost. Buying larger quantities and freezing extras can also help cut down the price per pound.
Preparation: Do Bone-In or Boneless Hams Require More Work?
Most HoneyBaked hams come fully cooked and glazed, minimizing prep work. However, a few differences exist:
-
Boneless hams can be served straight from the fridge. Bone-in hams take 1-2 hours to come to room temperature before carving.
-
Carving around the bone takes more time and skill than slicing boneless ham. Have sharp knives and kitchen shears on hand.
-
Weighing and portioning boneless ham is simpler since the bone isn’t a factor.
-
You can bake boneless hams whole or in halves. Bone-in hams should be baked whole, with the bone adding stability.
-
Leftover boneless ham is easier to store. Bone-in ham leftovers require snipping meat from around the bone.
Overall, boneless, pre-carved hams require less prep and effort at serving time. But some enjoy the classic presentation of a bone-in ham.
Taste Test: How Do Bone-In and Boneless Hams Compare?
Now for the million dollar question – which tastes better, bone-in or boneless HoneyBaked ham? Several factors come into play when evaluating the flavor.
First, bone-in ham often boasts a richer, meatier taste. The bone adds depth of flavor as the meat cooks surrounding it. Fat marbling through the meat also enhances the taste.
However, boneless ham offers a few advantages too. The meat is generally leaner, with less fat. The ham glaze coats each slice evenly with no bulky bone. Slices are uniform in shape for even cooking.
Much depends on your preferences for bold, porky flavor vs. milder, leaner taste. Those who love rich, fatty cuts usually prefer bone-in for the added flavor dimensions.
What the Experts Say: Bone-In vs. Boneless HoneyBaked Ham
To further compare bone-in and boneless hams, I surveyed some fellow food experts. Here are some of their thoughts on the great HoneyBaked ham debate:
“I personally prefer the bone-in ham. The bone seems to make the meat more moist and tender during cooking. The leftover bone also makes an excellent starting point for soups or beans.” – James, Chef
“If I’m serving a large gathering, I go with boneless. It’s easier to carve and serve quickly, with slices that are consistently thick. However, the bone-in ham wins for flavor.” – Clara, Caterer
“As a busy parent, I choose boneless hams for the convenience. Less prep and easier serving is worth the trade-off of slightly less rich taste.” – Amanda, Mom
“While boneless may be quicker, I think starting with a bone-in ham and then removing the bone after cooking gives you the best of both worlds – great taste and easy serving.” – Michael, Barbecue Competitor
As you can see, our panel has some divided opinions! Bone-in hams shine flavor-wise, while boneless offers convenience. Much depends on your needs and preferences.
Serving a Crowd? Try a Boneless HoneyBaked Ham
When serving a large gathering like Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner, boneless hams make catering easier. Pre-cut slices mean you don’t have to carve at the table. Uniform pieces cook evenly and are easy to portion control.
If you have guests with special dietary needs, boneless ham may be a better pick too. It’s easier to find and serve leaner pieces without heavy marbling. Diabetic, low sodium, and heart healthy diets benefit from boneless.
For Tailgating or Picnics, Choose Boneless Hams
If you need an easy protein for tailgating, camping or picnicking, boneless ham is handy. It travels well, slices neatly for sandwiches or snacks, and doesn’t require utensils to eat.
The boneless ham’s uniform shape also leaves less waste compared to meats cooked and served on the bone. Plus, it won’t leave you with messy bones to dispose of outdoors. Grab some boneless ham for your next outdoor adventure.
Hosting a Formal Dinner Party? Impress with a Bone-In Ham
Want to serve a stunning centerpiece at your next dinner party? A bone-in ham is sure to wow your guests. Carved tableside, it makes an impressive presentation. The bone adds dramatic visual appeal as well.
The rich, nuanced flavor of bone-in ham pairs beautifully with fancy side dishes too. It feels upscale and special – perfect for date nights, New Year’s Eve and other glamorous occasions.
Try Both! Offer Bone-In and Boneless for a Crowd
When in doubt, offer guests the best of both worlds. Order a bone-in ham for the main table and boneless ham for self-serve side tables.
The bone-in ham makes a beautiful carving station centrepiece. Meanwhile, the boneless ham provides easy serving for diners to create their own plates. It also gives ample leaner options for those monitoring fat or sodium.
With both types on hand, you can accommodate all preferences and dietary needs. Leftovers are easy to portion and store too. It’s a win-win!
Get Creative with Leftovers!
One perk of HoneyBaked hams? Leftovers galore! Here are some delicious ways to put them to use:
-
Ham salad sandwiches with mustard, pickles and cheese
-
Eggs baked in ham cups for brunch
-
Ham fried rice or pasta carbonara
-
Hearty ham and bean soup
-
Chef’s salad with ham, turkey, cheese and greens
-
Ham layered omelets or quiches
-
Freeze small portions for future omelets, pasta dishes and more
Don’t let any go to waste! Both bone-in and boneless hams make terrific leftovers.
Bone-In vs. Boneless HoneyBaked Ham: The Verdict
When it comes to HoneyBaked ham, both the boneless and bone-in varieties have merit. Keep these key factors in mind when deciding:
-
Bone-in ham offers bolder pork flavor, while boneless is more mildly flavored. Pick the taste profile you prefer.
-
Boneless ham costs more but provides easier prep, storage and serving. It’s ideal for large gatherings.
-
Bone-in ham makes a beautiful presentation cooked and carved whole. It’s great for intimate dinners.
-
Both types have excellent leftovers potential, so plan ahead to use them up.
There’s no wrong choice between bone-in and boneless ham. Let your needs, taste and budget guide you or purchase both for maximum flexibility. Your holiday table will be sure to shine with a HoneyBaked ham as the centerpiece.