The Complete Guide to Cooking Crispy, Delicious Turkey Bacon in Your Toaster Oven

Turkey bacon has become an increasingly popular alternative to traditional pork bacon. With its lower fat content and delicious flavor many bacon lovers are switching over to this healthier option. But cooking turkey bacon can be tricky if you don’t know the right techniques. The good news is that your trusty toaster oven is actually the perfect appliance for cooking up evenly browned crispy turkey bacon.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll walk through everything you need to know to make delicious turkey bacon in a toaster oven, from start to finish You’ll learn tips on choosing the right turkey bacon, how to prep and arrange the slices, what temperature and cook times work best, and how to ensure your bacon comes out perfectly crispy every time

Benefits of Cooking Turkey Bacon in a Toaster Oven

Before we dive into the cooking steps, let’s look at why a toaster oven is so well-suited for making turkey bacon:

  • Even heating: Toaster ovens distribute heat more evenly than skillets or microwaves. This allows the turkey bacon to cook through consistently.

  • Crispy texture: The hot, dry heat of a toaster oven produces crisper turkey bacon than some other cooking methods.

  • No splattering: Cooking bacon in a skillet can cause splattering grease. A toaster oven contains the mess.

  • Quick cooking: Turkey bacon cooks up faster in a toaster oven than an regular oven.

  • Ease of use: Toaster ovens are simple to use. Just toast, flip occasionally, and you’ve got perfect bacon.

Now that you know the advantages, let’s go over how to shop for and prep turkey bacon for the toaster oven.

Selecting and Preparing Turkey Bacon

Choosing the Right Turkey Bacon

Not all turkey bacon is created equal. Here’s what to look for:

  • Minimal additives: Choose turkey bacon with no added nitrites or nitrates when possible for a healthier option.

  • Higher meat content: Opt for turkey bacon with a higher percentage of actual turkey meat over fillers and additives. This gives you better texture and flavor.

  • Reputable brand: Stick to well-known turkey bacon brands that use high quality ingredients. Store brands can be hit or miss.

  • Thicker slices: Thicker sliced turkey bacon holds up better in a toaster oven than very thin slices.

Proper Handling for Best Results

Before cooking your turkey bacon, follow these tips:

  • If frozen, thaw completely in the fridge overnight before cooking.

  • Pat slices dry with paper towels. Excess moisture prevents crisping.

  • Lay bacon flat on a plate. Curled slices will cook unevenly.

  • Trim excess fat off slices if desired. This reduces overall fat content.

Now the turkey bacon is prepped and ready to cook!

Step-by-Step Toaster Oven Cooking Guide

Cooking turkey bacon in a toaster oven takes just a few easy steps. Here’s exactly how to do it for perfect results every time:

1. Preheat Toaster Oven

  • Heat oven to 400°F degrees. This high temp crisps up the turkey bacon nicely.

  • Give oven 5-10 minutes to fully preheat before adding bacon.

2. Prepare Baking Sheet

  • Line baking sheet with aluminum foil for easy cleanup.

  • For optimal heat circulation, use a wire rack on top of the foil.

3. Add Turkey Bacon

  • Arrange slices in single layer on prepared baking sheet without overlapping.

  • Overcrowding leads to uneven cooking. Leave a bit of space between each slice.

4. Cook the Bacon

  • Cook at 400°F for approximately 10-15 minutes. Thinner slices may take less time.

  • For chewier bacon, err on the lower end of cook time. For extra crispy bacon, cook longer.

  • Flip bacon halfway through for even crispness on both sides.

5. Check for Doneness

  • Look for bacon slices to be browned and crispy around the edges.

  • If still limp or underdone, continue cooking in 2-3 minute increments, checking frequently.

  • Use tongs to lift a slice and check texture. It should be set and crispy, not bendable.

6. Remove and Drain

  • When done, remove baking sheet from oven and transfer bacon to a paper towel lined plate.

  • This absorbs excess grease for crisper bacon.

  • Let cool 1-2 minutes before eating.

And that’s all there is to it! With these simple steps, you’ll achieve perfectly cooked turkey bacon from your toaster oven every time.

Toaster Oven Turkey Bacon Mistakes to Avoid

Now that you know the right way to make turkey bacon in a toaster oven, here are a few common mistakes to avoid:

  • Cooking at too low of a temp. Go with 400°F for crispy bacon.

  • Overcrowding the baking sheet with overlapping slices. Leave space between each slice.

  • Not patting the turkey bacon dry before cooking. Excess moisture prevents crisping.

  • Forgetting to flip the slices halfway through. This leads to uneven cooking.

  • Cooking too long and burning the bacon. Watch it closely near the end.

  • Not draining on paper towels after cooking. This causes sogginess.

As long as you steer clear of these errors and follow the proper technique, you’ll get picture-perfect turkey bacon every time from your toaster oven!

Tips for Extra Flavorful Turkey Bacon

Plain turkey bacon right out of the toaster oven is delicious, but if you want to kick the flavor up a notch, try these easy ideas:

  • Add a dash of maple syrup or brown sugar to the slices before cooking.

  • Sprinkle with Cajun seasoning or smoky paprika before or after cooking.

  • Glaze with your favorite barbecue sauce just after removing from the oven.

  • Top cooked turkey bacon with fresh cracked pepper.

  • Fold cooked turkey

Cooking Easy Bacon in the Toaster Oven~Turkey Bacon vs Pork Bacon


Can you cook bacon in the toaster oven?

Is regular or thick cut best when baking bacon in a toaster oven? You can use either regular or thick cut bacon in a countertop oven, but thick cut may require a longer cooking time. Consider using an air fry or convection setting for thick bacon to help caramelize the edges.

How do you know when turkey bacon is cooked?

Cook turkey bacon as specified on the package. Always cook to well-done, 165°F as measured by a meat thermometer.

Can turkey bacon get crispy?

Once you make turkey bacon in the oven, you will never make it any other way! Perfectly crispy and zero mess to clean up, this is our favorite way to cook bacon!

How to cook turkey bacon in the oven?

To cook turkey bacon in the oven, preheat the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit and place the oven rack in the center. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper for easy clean-up (optional). Lay the turkey bacon slices on the baking rack and place it in the preheated oven.

Can you cook turkey bacon in a toaster oven?

This recipe for turkey bacon works also in a smaller toaster oven just as well as in your regular oven. For toaster oven times, I would watch it and cook it a few minutes less. Still place the bacon strips on the toaster oven pan that comes with most models.

How to cook bacon in a toaster oven?

Place a sheet pan under the wire tray in your toaster oven. You should find a sheet pan that fits on the bottom of your toaster oven. If any bacon drips during the cooking process, a sheet pan will catch this. It is easier to remove the pan and clean it than clean the bottom of a toaster oven.

How do you cook pork belly in a toaster oven?

If you like to splurge & enjoy regular pork belly at a time, there is no better way to cook a few slices than with my recipe for toaster oven bacon. Turn the oven to 425° to preheat. Next, you will spray your baking sheets with cooking spray. Finally, evenly space out the turkey bacon on the sheet pans.

Leave a Comment