The Complex History of Hindus and Beef Eating
Beef has become a hot button issue in India today But contrary to popular belief, beef eating has a long and complicated history in Hinduism.
The Vedas the oldest Hindu scriptures dating back to 1500 BCE mention cow sacrifice and beef consumption. But around the Buddha’s time in the 6th century BCE, vegetarianism started gaining prominence among Brahmins and upper castes. They began forbidding beef on religious grounds. But many lower castes continued eating beef as a source of nourishment and protein.
Over the centuries, the cow became a revered symbol of life and fertility in Hinduism The ancient epic Mahabharata tells the story of a drought and famine ending when the earth goddess appeared as a cow and allowed the king to milk her. This mythical story shows the transition from hunting wild cattle to preserving their lives for milk and ploughing fields The cow came to represent motherhood and the generous giving of life-sustaining milk.
But even in 300 BCE-300 CE when the Mahabharata was composed, many Hindus still ate beef on special occasions. Ancient Hindu law books like Manusmriti sanctioned guests being honored with the ritual slaying of a cow or bull. Lower castes that couldn’t afford expensive vegetarian foods often subsisted on beef.
But the cow protection movement arose in the late 19th century as a symbol of Hindu identity under British colonial rule. Beef eating became associated with Islam and Christianity, while vegetarianism defined Hindu purity. Gandhi tried to make cow protection a national cause, seeing the cow as the image of Mother India herself. But while promoting vegetarianism, Gandhi did not call for a nationwide beef ban out of respect for India’s religious diversity.
So in today’s India, why has beef eating become such a fraught issue tied to Hindu-Muslim conflicts? With the rise of Hindu nationalism since the 1990s, anti-beef laws and vigilante cow protection squads have proliferated. These policies disproportionately target Muslims and lower-caste Hindus who consume beef. 97% of cow vigilante attacks have occurred since Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist BJP came into power in 2014.
Now let’s look at what actually happens if a Hindu person violates these modern taboos and eats beef:
-
Social ostracization: In traditional Hindu society, the strongest punishment is being outcast by your community. Eating forbidden beef would be seen as a sin making you unfit to enter temples or participate in rituals. Your family could wash their hands of you to protect their social standing.
-
Violence from vigilantes: In recent years, cow protection gangs have brutally attacked or lynched people (often Muslims) accused of slaughtering cows or transporting beef. These vigilantes don’t care if you’re Hindu or not – getting caught with beef puts your life at risk.
-
Legal repercussions: Since Modi came into power, Indian states have enacted stricter anti-cow slaughter laws with punishments up to life imprisonment. Transporting or consuming beef is illegal in states like Gujarat with heavily Hindu populations.
-
Loss of business opportunities: Avoiding beef is necessary to be seen as a pious Hindu business owner. If customers discover you eat beef, you may lose their Hindu patronage. This economic impact deters beef eating.
-
Strained family relations: Eating beef could seriously damage relations with your orthodox Hindu parents, spouse, relatives etc. who see it as a sinful taboo. They may see you as rejecting Hindu norms and identity.
-
Difficulty marrying: Hindus who eat beef could struggle to find a spouse among devout communities, potentially hurting marriage prospects. Conforming to vegetarian expectations improves chances of arranging a suitable Hindu marriage.
-
Inner guilt/conflict: If you grow up believing cows are sacred, beef consumption could conflict with your conscience, values, and self-identity as a Hindu. Even if legal, you may feel guilty for violating taboos you’re conditioned to see as evil.